One of the reasons I review this list so often is when an announcer talks about how great a quarterback is, I’ll know how he compares to other QB’s in his conference and across the country. Is he a Heisman candidate? Is he a NFL prospect? If so, why is he rated so low?
Heisman voters look at the best player on the best team. Like a beauty pageant, any flaw counts points off. Hardly any are perfect. NFL scouts look more at physical attributes (size, arm strength) that performance on the field.
New this week: last week’s rating at the far right. One bad game can drop a QB ten or more spots.
1. 91.6 Lamar Jackson, Louisville (2) 90.9
2. 91.6 Sam Darnold, Southern California (1) 91.4
3. 90.3 Baker Mayfield, Oklahoma (4) 86.9
4. 90.2 Jake Browning, Washington (3) 89.7
8. 84.5 Mitch Trubisky, North Carolina (7) 84.6 (above)
11. 79.4 Deondre Francois, Florida State freshman (12)
12. 79.0 Wilton Speight, Michigan (30) 72.6
13. 78.6 Greg Ward, Houston (10) 82.0
16. 77.8 Trevor Knight, Texas A&M (17) 77.2
17. 77.7 Jalen Hurts, Alabama freshman
18. 77.7 Skyler Howard, West Virginia
19. 77.5 Sean White, Auburn (23) 74.4
22. 77.3 Chad Kelly, Ole Miss (11) 79.6
23. 75.9 Jerod Evans, Virginia Tech (28) 72.8
24. 75.3 Austin Allen, Arkansas (21) 75.2
25. 75.2 Deshaun Watson, Clemson (20) 75.4
26. 73.8 Nathan Peterman, Pittsburgh (26) 73.2
32. 71.2 Tommy Armstrong, Nebraska (25) 73.6
33. 70.9 Seth Russell, Baylor (34)
35. 69.9 Jesse Ertz, Kennesaw State (45) 66.7
37. 68.7 Eric Dungey, Syracuse (46) 66.5
38. 68.3 Brett Rypien, Boise State (32)
39. 68.3 Mason Rudolph, Oklahoma State (35)
41. 68.0 Danny Etling, Louisiana State
43. 67.3 JT Barrett, Ohio State (33)
44. 67.1 Nick Fitzgerald, Mississippi State (42)
45. 66.6 Justin Thomas, Georgia Tech (40) 67.8
47. 65.6 Taysom Hill, Brigham Young (39) 67.9
48. 65.0 Joshua Dobbs, Tennessee (49) 64.4
49. 64.0 Shane Buechele, Texas freshman (41) 67.7
50. 63.5 DeShone Kizer, Notre Dame (50)
52. 62.8 Brad Kaaya, Miami (55) 62.2 (below)
54. 62.1 Josh Rosen, UCLA (57)
55. 62.1 Ryan Finley, NC State (44) 66.8
57. 61.6 Trace McSorley, Penn State (52) 63.6
61. 59.1 Drew Lock, Missouri (75) 54.0
69. 55.4 Mitch Leidner, Minnesota (63)
72. 54.9 Jacob Eason, Georgia freshman (66) 56.1
76. 53.4 John Wolford, Wake Forest (74) 54.0
79. 52.3 Conner Manning, Georgia State (79)
80. 52.0 Kurt Benkert, Virginia (65) 56.1
81. 52.0 Ryan Burns, Stanford (73) 54.3
83. 50.8 Luke Del Rio, Florida (80) 51.6
85. 50.3 Daniel Jones, Duke (83)
89. 48.7 Patrick Towles, Boston College (86)
93. 46.7 Kevin Ellison, Georgia Southern (87)
108. 39.3 Kyle Shurmur, Vanderbilt (112)
126. 22.3 Brandon McIlwain, South Carolina freshman (126) 23.9